Catering Menus

wedding special events (Print)holiday menu (Print)everyday menu (Print)picnic menu (Print)

Breakfast

Breakfast Box

$9.00

Grab and go! Choice of bagel with cream cheese or breakfast muffin, fresh cut-up fruit and yogurt with granola

Farmers Market Breakfast Casserole

$12.95

Italian chicken sausage, onion, sliced mushrooms shredded hash browns, cheddar cheese, green peppers, tomatoes and eggs baked till golden brown. Served with fresh fruit, bagels and muffins

Baked Oatmeal

$9.00

Rolled oats with dried cranberries & spiced apples, baked & topped with a vanilla cream sauce served with fresh fruit salad and assorted muffins

Spinach and Ham Gruyere Frittata

$12.50

Delicate baked egg frittata with fresh spinach, black forest ham and rich gruyere cheese

Good Morning

$11.95

Scrambled eggs, bacon, pork or turkey sausage, potatoes o’ brian, bagels, muffins and seasonal fruit

Build Your Own Breakfast Burrito

$11.50

Scrambled eggs, green pepper, tomato, onion, blended cheese, cilantro and choice of chorizo, sausage or bacon. Served with Flour tortilla, salsa, fresh fruit, and hashbrowns or Potatoes O’ Brian.

Continental

$9.95

An assortment of fresh donuts, Danish, bagels, muffins, and seasonal fruit. Served with cream cheese, jam, and butter

Country Breakfast

$11.95

Scrambled Eggs, biscuits and sausage gravy, bacon, and seasonal fruit

Homemade Pancakes

$10.50/+

Home Style Corned Beef Hash

$12.95

Served with scrambled eggs, fresh fruit salad, and assorted muffins

Appetizer

Smoked Salmon Platter

$69.95/S

$94.95/M

$124.95/L

Norwegian style smoked Atlantic salmon thinly sliced and beautifully displayed with boiled colored baby potatoes, red onion, sliced cucumbers, sliced radish, sliced cherry tomato, hardboiled egg, caper guests, lemon wedges, fresh dill, cream cheese and rye cocktail bread

Street Skewers

$59.95/S

$79.95/M

$99.95/L

An assortment of skewers fashioned off street vendors: beef bulgogi, lemongrass pork and chicken satay

Vegetarian Platter

$59.95/S

$79.95/M

$99.95/L

An inviting platter of vegetarian bites including: roasted vegetable skewers; mini cucumber, cream cheese, avocado and sprout wraps; asparagus and caramelized onion tartlets; caprese skewers – cherry tomato, fresh mozzarella and fresh basil

Get Pickled and Go Nuts Platter

$64.95/S

$84.95/M

$104.95/L

An enticing display of pickled vegetables, spiced nuts and Wisconsin cheese curds

Salsa Trio

$49.95/S

$59.95/M

$79.95/L

Your guests will say ‘ole to our homemade guacamole, Pico de Gallo and black bean corn salsa served with seasoned homemade tortilla chips

Chips and Dips

$49.95/S

$59.95/M

$79.95/L

Homemade spinach and sour cream dip, roasted red pepper hummus paired with homemade pita chips and our famous homemade kettle chips

Vegetable Crudité

$42.95/S

$59.95/M

$77.95/L

Seasonal garden vegetables served with organic dill dip and red pepper hummus

Fresh Fruit

$54.95/S

$72.95/M

$94.95/L

Fresh seasonal fruit

Wisconsin Cheese Tray

$53.95/S

$72.95/M

$90.95/L

An assortment of Wisconsin cheese selections served with an assortment of crackers, grapes and candied nuts

Cheese and Sausage Tray

$69.95/S

$88.95/M

$107.95/L

Our Wisconsin cheese offerings served with a variety of local sausages and crackers

Artisan Cheese Platter

$81.95/+

An inspiring display of aged cheddar, Havarti, Manchego and Bleu cheese accompanied with baguette, crackers, dried fruit, nuts and preserves • Small $81.95 | Medium $101.95 | Large $121.95

Italian Platter

$69.95/+

Roasted vegetables, salami, cherry tomatoes, marinated artichoke hearts, assorted Italian cheeses, marinated olives• Small $69.95 | Medium $89.95 | Large $107.95

Mini Sandwich Platter

$36.00/per dozen

Assortment of sandwiches on mini-rolls that includes: curried chicken salad; roasted turkey breast with cranberry mayo; tomato, mozzarella and basil with balsamic mayo; tender roast beef and cheddar with Dijon mayo.

Mini Wrap Platter

$36.00/per dozen

Selection of mini wraps with following fillings; pesto mayo, grilled chicken with spinach and feta; roasted vegetables with mozzarella; buffalo chicken; shaved roast beef with romaine, tomato and Dijon mayo.

Wraps and Minis

$36.00/per dozen

Selection of our most popular artisanal wraps and sandwiches on mini rolls, and assorted wraps.

Cold Hors D’ Oeuvres

Smoked Salmon Rye Canape

$54.95/24 pieces

Goat cheese, thin slices of smoked salmon, shaved radish and a watercress sprig on top of cocktail rye bread.

BLT Crostini

$42.95/24 pieces

Toasted baguette topped with herb mayo, lettuce, tomato and applewood bacon.

Caprese Skewers

$42.95/24 pieces

Cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella ovoline and basil drizzled with a balsamic reduction.

Antipasto Skewers

$44.95/24 pieces

Provolone, salami, cherry tomato and pepperoncini.

Fresh Fruit Kabobs

$38.95/24 pieces

Cut fresh seasonal fruit on a skewer.

Cucumber Canapés

$40.95/24 pieces

Classic finger sandwich on rye with herbed cream cheese and mayo, fresh cucumber and topped with diced pimento and dill.

Chicken Avocado Bacon Slider

$69.95/24 pieces

Pepper jack cheese, avocado spread with cilantro, bacon, grilled chicken breast, tomato, caramelized onion on a slider bun.

Shrimp Cocktail

$59.95/24 pieces

Jumbo steamed shrimp with classic cocktail sauce and lemon.

Ricotta & Black Olive Crostini

$42.95/24 pieces

With lemon zest and mint. Amazing combination.

Bistro Beef Bites

$59.95/24 pieces

Deli roast beef on snack rye with horseradish cream spread topped with half grape tomato and sour cream.

Tomato Bruschetta

$42.95/24 pieces

Italian classic, toasted baguette slices topped with fresh diced, onion, garlic, olive oil and fresh basil.

Deviled Eggs

$34.95/24 pieces

Classic deviled eggs with horseradish, vinegar, mayo and smoked paprika.

Siracha Deviled Eggs with Bacon

$36.95/24 pieces

Live a little!

Hot Hors D’ Oeuvres

Angus Cheddar Sliders

$79.95/24 pieces

Angus slider with cheddar cheese and condiments.

Buffalo Chicken Slider

$69.95/24 pieces

Chicken breast fritter in Buffalo sauce on a mini roll with lettuce and bleu cheese dressing.

Mini Street Taco Quesadilla

$49.95/24 pieces

Shredded chicken, shredded Mexican cheese, jalapeno, pico de gallo, cilantro, red onion and spices in a grilled flour tortilla. Olé!

Teriyaki Chicken Skewer

$45.95/24 pieces

Grilled teriyaki marinated chicken breast cubes on a skewer.

Grilled Asian Steak Kabob

$69.95/24 pieces

Cubes of sirloin marinated in a delicious Asian sesame sauce grilled with red onion and pineapple.

Breaded Chicken Tenders

$42.95/24 pieces

Served with choice of BBQ or ranch dressing.

Mini Meatball Skewer

$39.95/24 pieces

Beef and pork mini meatballs on a spike with marinara or BBQ sauce.

Jalapeno Popper

$44.95/24 pieces

Our homemade jalapeno pepper stuffed with cream cheese, wrapped in bacon and baked. Can you eat just one?

Mini Chicken Cordon Bleu

$48.95/24 pieces

Mini chicken cordon bleus with Swiss cheese and smoked ham, coated in bread crumbs and baked.

Mini Beef Wellington

$79.95/24 pieces

Beef tenderloin simmered in a savory sauce of wine, mushrooms and herbs, then wrapped in a flaky French pastry.

Spinach Artichoke Tartlet

$55.95/45 pieces

Won’t last long! Spinach, artichoke, parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese, cream cheese, sour cream and a touch of cayenne mixed and baked in a phyllo tartlet.

Buffalo Wings

$49.95/24 pieces

Our breaded and deep-fried wings. Choose between buffalo, sesame ginger or honey soy sauce. Served with celery and bleu cheese dip.

Rumaki

$39.95/24 pieces

Bacon wrapped chestnuts with soy glaze.

Sausage Stuffed Mushroom Caps

$49.95/24 pieces

Large mushroom caps generously stuffed with a spicy Italian sausage stuffing.

Spinach & Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms

$45.95/24 pieces

Mushroom caps stuffed with feta, spinach and cream cheese then dusted with bread crumbs.

Vegetable Spring Roll

$39.95/24 pieces

A colorful mixture of Chinese vegetables tossed with soy sauce, sesame oil and a touch of fresh ginger wrapped in a spring roll wrapper. Served with sweet and sour sauce.

Crab Cakes

$69.95/24 pieces

Full sized crab cakes topped with a lemon mustard and tarragon aioli. Served with remoulade sauce.

Meatballs

$34.95/24 pieces

Cocktail meatballs in your choice of Swedish or our homemade BBQ sauce.

Potato Skins

$49.95/24 pieces

Baked half potato skin filled with bacon, cheddar and topped with a dollop of sour cream and chopped chives.

Mini Quiche

$49.95/24 pieces

An assortment of three cheese, mushroom, classic French and Florentine.

Italian Beef Bites

$39.95/24 pieces

Thinly sliced Italian beef with mozzarella and hot giardiniera wrapped up in a crispy wonton wrapper served with au jus.

Rueben Rolls

$39.95/24 pieces

Chopped corned beef handrolled with swiss cheese and sauerkraut in a crispy wonton wrapper. Served with house made thousand island dressing.

Italian Sausage

$59.95/24 links sliced

With peppers and onions.

DELI WRAP AND SANDWICH BUFFET | $16

Roasted Turkey Breast Pesto Sandwich

Swiss Cheese, red onion, pesto, lettuce, and tomato on focaccia bread.

Loaded Steer

Tender sliced roast beef, creamy horseradish mayo, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion and arugula in a wrap.

Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich

Roast Turkey breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, red onion, cucumber applewood smoked bacon on choice of white, wheat or rye.

Homemade Chicken or Tuna Salad

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Romaine, tomato, grilled chicken breast, parmesan and croutons, and Caesar dressing in a wrap.

Ham and Cheese on Rye

Black forest ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Dijon on rye bread.

Portabella

$13.00

Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese on a focaccia bread.

ARTISANAL SANDWICHES & WRAPS BOX LUNCH | $16

Little Italy

$16.00

Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, olive oil, red wine vinegar, oregano, hot peppers, lettuce, tomato, served on focaccia bread.

Portabella

$16.00

Grilled portabella cap topped with red onions, tomatoes, cucumbers, spinach, roasted red peppers, and pesto cream cheese on focaccia bread.

Chicken or Tuna Salad Croissants

$16.00

Loaded Steer

$16.00

Tender sliced roast beef, creamy horseradish mayo, sliced tomato, cheddar cheese, pickled red onion, and arugula in a wrap.

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$16.00

Romaine, tomato, grilled chicken breast, parmesan and croutons, Caesar dressing in a wrap.

Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich

$16.00

Roast turkey breast, avocado, romaine lettuce, red onion, cucumber applewood smoked bacon on choice of white, wheat, or rye.

Salad Boxes

Chicken Caesar

$14.00

Grilled chicken breast on a bed of romaine lettuce, tossed with shredded parmesan cheese, croutons, served with homemade Caesar dressing

Chicken BLT Salad

$15.00

Grilled chicken breast on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce, tossed bacon, hard boiled eggs, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and avocado, served with crumbled bleu cheese and choice of dressing

Chef Salad

$15.00

Sliced ham and turkey on a bed of crisp iceberg lettuce, tossed with hard boiled eggs, onions, tomatoes, peppers, and cheese

Fiesta Chicken

$15.00

Crispy fried chicken breast on a bed of fresh greens with onion, pepper, tomato, shredded cheddar jack cheese blend and black olives served in a crispy tortilla shell, with salsa and sour cream

Hot Bacon Cobb

$15.00

Grilled chicken breast on a bed of fresh baby spinach with red onion, tomato, mushroom, boiled egg, swiss cheese, and our house made hot bacon dressing

Harvest Cobb

$15.00

Char grilled chicken breast over romaine with chopped eggs, dried cranberries, fresh apples, blue cheese crumbles, applewood smoked bacon, pecans and peas and finished with a homemade poppy seed vinaigrette

Waldorf

$15.00

Char grilled chicken breast tossed with crispy green apples, grapes, roasted walnuts and celery served with a homemade Waldorf dressing

Apple Pecan Arugula

$15.00

Char grilled chicken breast tossed with dried cranberries, roasted pecans, gala apples, feta cheese, and arugula, finished with a homemade lemon vinaigrette

Summer Berry Salad

$15.00

Grilled chicken breast atop crispy lettuce, tomatoes, blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries, toasted almonds, mandarin oranges, cucumbers, feta cheese, and a homemade raspberry walnut vinaigrette

House Salad

$9.25

Grand Buffet

Lasagna

Featuring papa Luigi’s homemade favorite! Fresh pasta layered with seasoned ground beef, ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, topped with Papa Luigi’s signature marinara

Papa Luigi’s Fettuccine Chicken Alfredo

Chicken Piccata

Tender chicken breast, breaded and sautéed in a white wine, lemon butter caper enhanced sauce.

Classic Beef Stroganoff

Tender beef tips sautéed with mushrooms and onions and simmered in a rich sour cream and burgundy sauce. Served with egg noodles.

Slow Cooked Beef Roast

Boneless sliced short rib slow cooked and topped with a rich homemade gravy.

Beef Tips Bourguignonne

Tender tips of beef, seared and served in a red wine and demi glaze sauce.

Eggplant Parmesan

Thinly sliced eggplant, breaded in egg wash and seasoned breadcrumbs, fried then layered with Papa Luigi’s marinara, mozzarella and baked.

Mom’s Meatloaf

Pan-seared homemade meatloaf, topped with homemade rosemary mushroom gravy.

Roast Turkey Dinner

Slow-roasted turkey with sage and herbs.

Roasted Chicken

Skin-on chicken pieces rubbed with olive oil and spices, then baked with fresh rosemary until golden brown.

Honey Baked Ham

Smoked pit ham and served with a pineapple glaze

Herb Crusted Pork Loin

Thyme and rosemary crusted loin.

STARCHES:

Rice Pilaf

Classic Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Baked Potato

with sour cream and butter

Oven Roasted Rosemary Potatoes

Mac N Cheese

Butter Garlic Pasta

Pasta Champagne Sauce

VEGETABLES:

Honey Glazed Carrots

Green Beans Amandine

Garlic Parmesan Roasted Broccoli

Tuscan Sautéed Vegetables

yellow squash, zucchini, carrots, green beans, red pepper

Whole Kernel Corn, Basil and Red Pepper Medley

Steamed California Vegetables

Broccoli, cauliflower, and carrots

Executive Buffet

Slow Roasted Beef Brisket

Moist and tender slow-roasted brisket served in a horseradish thyme cream sauce.

Spinach and Artichoke Stuffed Chicken Breast

Baked all-natural chicken breast stuffed with spinach, artichoke, cream cheese, mozzarella and herbs.

Stuffed Pork Chop

Slow-roasted pork chop stuffed with a rosemary gravy.

Braised Cabernet Short Ribs

Short ribs braised and slow cooked for 5 hours until fork tender. Add 2

Chicken Marsala

Bourbon Glazed Salmon

Atlantic salmon filet, brushed with homemade Bourbon glaze, then baked.

Butternut Squash Ravioli

In a sage brown butter sauce.

Goat Cheese Ravioli

Fluffy pillows of pasta filled with creamy goat cheese in a rich champagne sauce.

Parmesan Crusted Chicken

Boneless skinless chicken breast topped with a parmesan cream sauce, toasted bread crumbs and broiled.

STARCHES:

Roasted Cauliflower Puree

with parmesan and crispy onions

Long Grain Wild Rice

Whipped potatoes with fontina

Roasted Root Vegetables

Double Baked Potato

Fingerling roasted potatoes

VEGETABLES:

Garlic Parmesan Roasted Broccoli

Sautéed Zucchini and Squash

with garlic and parmesan

Braised Brussels Sprouts

in cider and bacon

Pan Seared Asparagus

Italian Buffet

PASTA ENTRÉES:

Pasta with Meatballs

Fettuccini Alfredo

Choose Chicken or Shrimp

Lasagna

Choose Meat or Spinach

Cheese or Beef Tortellini

Lasagna Rolls

Choose 4 Cheese, Italian Sausage or Spinach

Pasta Primavera

Italian Macaroni & Cheese

Crab Linguine Alfredo

$2.00

Sal’s Seafood Sensation

$2.00

Linguini pasta with sautéed shrimp, lobster, scallops, crab meat & garlic butter

Sausage

Italian sausage & peppers, Sausage Cacciatore

Veal

Veal Piccata ,Veal Parmigiana

CHICKEN:

Chicken Parmigiana

Baked Chicken Cacciatore

Oven Roasted Chicken

Parmesan Crusted Chicken

Chicken Caprese

Chicken Marsala

Chicken Piccata

BEEF:

Beef Upgrades

$3.00/+

Sicilian Steak

Steak Marsala

Braised Short Rib

Short Rib Ragu

Choice 2 Potatoes or 2 Pastas:

Pasta with Marinara, Garlic Butter, Alfredo or Champagne Sauce

Roasted Fingerling Potatoes

Roasted Baby Reds

Parsley Boiled Potatoes

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Sicilian Potato Salad

Papa Luigi's Favorites

Themed Packages

AMERICAN COMFORT FOOD

$21.00

Two entrées served with a garden salad, sage bread dressing, mashed potatoes and gravy, a vegetable, and a choice of cold side.

Poultry

Roasted Turkey Breast, Roasted Chicken, Meyer’s Famous Broasted Chicken, BBQ Chicken

Pork

Pork Tips and Noodles, Baked Pork Chops, Stuffed Pork Chop, Pork Chop Suey, Pork Goulash Served over egg noodles, Oven Baked Ham, Center Cut Pork Loin

Beef

Steak Stroganoff, Beef Stew, Swiss Steak, Beef Tips over Egg Noodles, Salisbury Steak

Other Favorites

Shepherd’s Pie, Stuffed Peppers, Cabbage Rolls

Cold Sides

Pasta Salad, Potato Salad, Coleslaw

ALL AMERICAN PICNIC

$16.00

Includes our choice of (2) grilled favorites along with a condiment platter, (lettuce, tomato, onion, sliced American cheese, & pickles), homemade chips & dip, baked beans, potato salad & buns.

Choice of 2:

BBQ PICNIC

$18.00

Includes your choice of (2) backyard favorites, cowboy baked beans, chips and dip, Meyer’s homemade creamy coleslaw, Meyer’s famous potato salad, and Peter Sciortino’s buns.

Shredded and Pulled BBQ

Chicken or Pork

BBQ Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf

BBQ Chicken

Wings

BBQ, Garlic Sesame, Buffalo or Mango Habanero

BBQ Meaty Ribs

+$2.00 per person

Slow Roasted Brisket

+$2.00 per person

PAPA LUIGI PIZZA PARTY

$17.00

Fresh Garden Salad, Mama Maria’s Famous Garlic Bread, a Variety of 16 in Pizzas (1 16 in feeds 5-6), and Your Choice of Baked Mostaccioli or Garlic Butter Pasta

Quick Picks

HOMESTYLE

$20.00

Baked Chicken, Sliced Baked Ham, Mashed Potatoes and Gravy, Bread Dressing with Gravy, Sweet Corn, Creamy Coleslaw, Garden Salad, Bread and Butter

THE GERMAN

$22.00

Sauerbraten, Pretzel Pork Cutlet, Spaetzle, Red Cabbage, German Potato Salad, Bread and Butter

SOUTHERNER

$22.00

Pulled Pork, Smoked Brisket, Famous Baked Beans, Creamy Coleslaw, Mac and Cheese, Cornbread Muffins and Honey Butter

TACO BAR

$13.00

Seasoned Ground Beef, Shredded Chicken, Rice and Beans, Tortillas, Chips and Salsa, Condiment Platter

THE SICILIAN

$22.00

Papa Luigi’s Lasagna, Chicken Cacciatore, Sicilian Veggies, Fettuccine Alfredo, Caesar Salad, Italian Bread and Butter

FAT TUESDAY

$19.00

Jambalaya, Shrimp Gumbo, Red Beans and Rice with Andouille Sausage, Meyer’s Creamy Coleslaw, Cornbread

FIESTA

$25.00

Bistec El Mexicana, Pork Enchiladas , Rice and Beans, Corn and Flour Tortillas, Chips and Salsa, Condiment Platter

Specialty Bars & Buffets

Potato Bar

$15.50

Includes: Sour cream, Butter and a First Choice salad with dressings | Add Soup +$3.00

Choose: Mashed or Baked

Choose 5 Toppings:

Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Gravy, Green Onions, Tomatoes, Sautéed Mushrooms and Green Peppers, Corn, and Broccoli

Salad Bar

$15.50

Includes: Assorted Homemade Dressings, Italian Bread and Butter, Fresh Fruit and Pasta Salad | Add Soup +$3.00

Fresh Romaine and Mixed Greens

Choose 5 Toppings:

Cheddar cheese, Feta cheese, bleu cheese crumbles, black olives, carrots, chopped hard boiled eggs, sliced red onion, mushrooms, broccoli florets, tomato, cucumber and cottage cheese, Pepperoncini and croutons

Choose 2 Meats:

Grilled Chicken Breast, Chopped Ham, Roasted Turkey Breast, Chicken Salad or Tuna Salad

Soup and Sandwich or Soup

$14.00

Served with your choice of homemade chips or coleslaw, bread and butter and oyster crackers

Choose Two:

One of our Homemade Soup Options, a Deli Platter of Breads, Meats, Cheese and Sandwich Fixings, or our House Salad with assorted House Made Dressings.

Street Taco Bar

$17.00

Served with: Fresh cilantro, shredded lettuce, guacamole, tomato, onion, lime crema, Mexican rice, fresh fruit, corn and flour tortillas

Choose Two:

Korean Beef Taco, Pulled Pork Carnitas, Fish Tacos

Make Your Own Fajitas

$24.00

Tender Grilled Chicken and Steak Marinated and Seasoned. Served with sautéed onions, red and green peppers, flour tortillas, refried beans, red rice, shredded cheese, jalapeno peppers, salsa, sour cream, homemade tortilla chips and churros | Add guacamole or pico de gallo +$3.00

Step One: Special Events Appetizer Packages

Package One

$7.00/guest

Choose Any Four:

-Cheese and Crackers

-Fresh Vegetable Platter

-Fresh Fruit Platter

-Bruschetta

-Mini BBQ Meatballs

-Liver Pate

BLT Crostini

Cucumber Canopies

Spinach and Artichoke Tartlets

Package Two

$8.00/guest

Choose Any Four (Can include options from Package One):

-Caprese Skewers

-Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms

-Chicken Tenders

-Reuben Dip

-Mac & Cheese Bites

Onion and Pesto Tartlets

Spinach and Artichoke Stuffed Mushrooms

Sriracha Deviled Eggs

Package Three

$10.50/guest

Choose Any Four (Can include options from Package One and Two):

-Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

-Chips and Dip

-Choice of Artichoke Dip, Dill Dip, French Onion Dip, Beer Cheese Dip, Reuben Dip or Buffalo Chicken Dip

-Smoked Salmon

-Italian Sausage and Peppers

-Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts

Philly Cheesesteak Rolls

Pork Belly Bites

Package Four

$14.50/guest

Choose Any Four (Can include any options for Package One, Two or Three):

-Charcuterie Board

-Antipasto Plates

-Crab Cakes

-Arancini (Rice Balls)

Cheesy Potato Croquettes

Cubano Bites

Shrimp Scampi

Fresh Bacon Wrapped Jalepeno Poppers

Step Two: Buffet Selections

The Original

$33.00/per guest

(2) Entrée Choices, (1) Specialty Side, (1) Potato, (1) Fresh Vegetable, (1) Buffet Salad, Dinner Rolls.

The Standard

$40.00/per guest

Carved Pork Loin, (2) Additional Entrée, (1) Specialty Side, (1) Potato, (1) Fresh Vegetable, (1) Buffet Salad, Dinner Rolls.

The Premiere

$44.00/per guest

Carved Turkey Breast, (2) Additional Entrée, (1) Specialty Side, (1) Potato, (1) Fresh Vegetable, (1) Buffet Salad, Dinner Rolls.

The Deluxe

$48.00/per guest

Carved Beef Sirloin, (2) Additional Entrées, (1) Specialty Side, (1) Potato, (1) Fresh Vegetable, (1) Buffet Salad, Dinner Rolls.

The Ultimate

$55.00/per guest

Carved Beef Tenderloin or Choice Angus Prime Rib, (2) Additional Entrées, (1) Specialty Side, (1) Potato, (1) Fresh Vegetable, (1) Buffet Salad, Dinner Rolls.

Step Three: Buffet Entrée Choices

CHICKEN:

Chicken Parmigiana

Italian breaded chicken breast, pan-fried and topped with marinara, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese.

Baked Chicken Cacciatore

Boneless, skinless chicken breast slow-cooked in a tasty red sauce with yellow and red peppers, sliced mushrooms, tomatoes, and herbs.

Oven Roasted Chicken

Skin-on chicken pieces rubbed with olive oil and spices, then baked with fresh rosemary until golden brown.

Parmesan Crusted Chicken

Boneless, skinless chicken breast topped with a parmesan cream, toasted bread crumbs and broiled.

Chicken Caprese

Natural chicken breast grilled and topped with fresh basil, Roma tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Marsala

Pan-fried chicken breast in a dry Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms and onions.

Chicken Piccata

Parmesan bread crumbs, white wine and lemon sauce, capers.

Coq Qu Vin

BEEF & PORK:

Braised Short Rib

Barbecue Ribs

Slow-cooked pork ribs, so tender, in Chef Gil’s homemade BBQ sauce.

Beef Spiedini

Thin sliced beef marinated in olive oil, hand-rolled and stuffed with Sicilian bread crumbs, topped with sautéed mushrooms and onions.

Open Faced Stuffed Pork Chops

Sliced Pork Loin

Thyme and rosemary crusted loin.

Pork Ribeye

SEAFOOD:

Sicilian Shrimp Scampi

Pinot Fennel Salmon

Burbon Salmon

Baked Cod

PASTAS:

Butternut Squash Ravioli

Goat Cheese Ravioli

Crab Lingini Alfedo

Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken

Homemade creamy alfredo.

Step Four: Service Packages

Classic Buffet

$4.50/per guest

Graceful Buffet

$7.50/per guest

Entrée Served Buffet Style | Formal Silver Chafers | Tables Bussed by First Choice Staff | Full China Package (dinner plate, salad plate, dessert plate, water glass, silverware) | Elaborate Preset Table (silverware, glass, water pitchers, salt/ pepper caddy, napkin, salad & dressing).

Established

$11.95/per guest

Butler Passed Appetizers | Meal Served Family Style to Table on Platters | Tables Bussed by First Choice Staff | Full China Package (dinner plate, salad plate, dessert plate, water glass, silverware) | Elaborate Preset Table (silverware, glass, water pitchers, salt/pepper caddy, napkin, salad & dressing).

Specialty Sides

Homemade Mac and Cheese

Pasta with Garlic Butter

Pasta with Champagne Sauce

Italian Pasta Salad

German Potato Salad

Roman Potato Salad

Meyer’s Famous Potato Salad

STARCHES:

Roasted Fingerling Potatoes

Roasted Red Potatoes

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Cheesy Hash Brown Potato Bake

FRESH VEGETABLES:

Bourbon Glazed Carrots

Roasted Asparagus

Roasted Brussel Sprouts

Green Beans Almandine

Steamed Broccoli with Hollandaise

Oven Roasted Cauliflower

Sweet Buttered Corn

BUFFET SALADS:

Garden Salad

Caesar Salad

Antipasto Salad

$2.00

Waldorf Salad

$1.00

Cobb Salad

$1.00

Apple Pecan Arugula Salad

$1.00

Strawberry Gorgonzola

$1.00

Additional Hors D’Oeuvres

Crab Cakes

$6.00

Chicken Tenders

$3.00

Boneless Wings

$4.00

Wonton Wrapped Mozzarella Sticks

$4.00

Rueben Rolls

$4.00

Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms

$4.00

Seafood Empanadas

$5.00

Smoked Salmon

$5.00

Liver Pate

$4.00

Sliced Italian Sausage with Peppers

$3.00

Meatballs

$3.00

Choice of Italian, Swiss, BBQ or German.

Toasted Bruschetta

$3.00

Caprese Salad

$4.00

Mediterranean Hummus Platter

$4.00

Chips and Dip

$5.00

Choice of Artichoke Dip, Dill, French Onion, Beer and Cheese, Rueben Dip and Buffalo Chicken Dip.

Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts

$4.00

Shrimp Cocktail

$7.00

Korean Pork Sliders

$4.00

Rollups

$3.00

Choice of Vegetable, Ham or Turkey.

Assorted Silver Dollar Sandwiches

$4.00

Fruit Platters

$3.00

Vegetable Platters

$3.00

Cheese and Cracker Plates

$4.00

Chacuturie Boards

$7.00

Anti Pasto Plate

$7.00

Conditions

Pricing

Prices and menus subject to change at anytime unless under contract.

Quality

We promise to use only quality products and ingredients and to hire quality employees.

Service

Providing quality food is fruitless without providing excellent, above and beyond service. We pride ourselves in our ability to listen to our customers and be adaptable to meet their peculiar needs with enthusiasm and a smile. We treat everyone like they are a part of our family.

Event Planning and Sales

Our knowledgeable staff will assist you in planning and execution of your event from A to Z. Please allow us to be your one stop and take care of all your event and catering needs. Call our office between 8 am and 4 pm, Monday - Friday. We are always available by appointment to meet your schedule.

Portions

It is our intent to provide you and your guests with an adequate amount of all foods based on our 25 years in the catering business. Please let us know in advance if you feel your event will require more than average consumption.

Dietary Needs

Please let us know in advance of any special dietary needs for you and any of your guests. We have options available for any dietary restrictions / requirements.

Guest Counts

Final guest counts are due 30 days before event date. After that we will accommodate increases, but due to commitments in scheduling, food and equipment we cannot decrease.

Deposits

Deposits are required for all special events and weddings to ensure service, staff and equipment for that chosen date. Final payment is due two weeks before the event by check or credit card.

Special Planning

Weddings and large special events require much more time than calculated in our menu pricing. A 22% service charge will be added for these events.

Santa’s Elf Holiday - Appetizers

Trio of Mini Sandwiches

Turkey breast, Black Forest ham, and tender roast beef on assorted mini rolls garnished with a pickle and black olive

Pigs in a Blanket

With honey mustard sauce

Cucumber Canapes

Sliced cucumber on cocktail rye with a dill sauce

Fiesta Dip and Chips

Layered Mexican dip and freshly made tortilla chips

Tater Kegs

Monster tots filled with bacon and cheddar cheese

Fresh Fruit Platter

An assortment of fresh seasonal fruit artfully displayed

Caprese Skewers

Fresh mozzarella balls, grape tomato, basil, balsamic glaze

Fresh Veggie Platter

Fresh seasonal veggies with ranch dip and roasted red pepper hummus

Classic Deviled Eggs

Buffalo Chicken Meatballs

Stuffed with bleu cheese and caramelized onion

Holiday Meatballs

Choose between our cranberry holiday BBQ sauce or classic Swedish

Wisconsin Cheese Platter

Assorted cubed Wisconsin cheeses with assorted crackers

Rumaki

Bacon wrapped water chestnuts marinated in a teriyaki sauce and roasted

Mother Claus Holiday - Appetizers

Warm Turkey Breast and Ham Sliders

Roasted turkey breast and sage gravy and hot Black Forest Ham on mini pretzel rolls with Dijon aioli

Trio of Mini Sandwiches

Turkey breast, Black Forest Ham, and tender roast beef on assorted mini rolls garnished with pickle and black olive

Chimichurri Steak Phyllo Bites

Tender roast beef, arugula, gorgonzola and chimichurri sauce in a phyllo cup

Fresh Fruit Kabobs

Fresh seasonal fruit on kabobs

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

With sliced baguettes and crackers

Roasted Grape Crostini

Roasted red grape on toasted baguette with fresh thyme and ricotta

Fresh Veggie Platter

Fresh seasonal veggies with ranch dip and roasted red pepper hummus

Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Platter

Wisconsin made assorted cheese and sausage beautifully arranged with assorted crackers

Mushroom Florentine Caps

Baked whole mushroom caps filled with spinach, parmesan, parsley, and breadcrumbs

Rumaki

Bacon wrapped water chestnuts marinated in teriyaki and roasted

Cucumber Canapes

Sliced cucumber on cocktail rye with a dill sauce

Santa’s Holiday - Appetizers

Cilantro Ginger Chicken Sliders

Chicken breast, mango salsa and chipotle mayo on butter top roll

Sliced Tenderloin Slider

Beef tenderloin, arugula, artichoke horseradish aioli on a mini-brioche roll

Mini Beef Wellington

Beef tenderloin in a savory sauce of wine, mushrooms and herbs, then wrapped in a flaky French pastry

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

Jumbo fresh shrimp, lemons, and cocktail sauce

Caprese Skewers

Fresh mozzarella balls, grape tomato, basil, and balsamic glaze

White Bean, Rosemary, and Garlic Crostini

Delicate combo of olive oil, a touch of garlic, cannellini beans and chopped fresh rosemary

Asiago Arancini

Asiago, parmesan, and romano cheeses

Maryland Lump Crab Dip

With sliced baguettes and assorted crackers

Crudite Platter

Fresh green beans, asparagus, zucchini, radish, grape tomato, carrot, cauliflower and broccoli with spinach artichoke dip and roasted red pepper hummus

Wisconsin Cheese and Sausage Platter

Wisconsin made assortment of cheese and sausage beautifully arranged and served with an assortment of crackers

Fresh Fruit Display

With roasted and candied bacon

Italiano Mushroom Cap

Baked whole mushroom caps filled with mild Italian sausage, breadcrumbs, parmesan, chopped parsley, and cream cheese

Jalapeno Bacon Empanadas

Jalapeno, crispy bacon, cream cheese, cilantro, and scallion

Classic Holiday Buffet

Elegant Holiday Buffet

SALAD:

Mixed Greens Salad

Mixed greens, fresh blueberries, candied walnuts, bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette

ENTRÉES (Choose Two):

Roasted Pork Loin with Apples

Brined in herbs and roasted with fresh apples, apple cognac cream sauce

Holiday Roast

Oven braised beef pot roast with bacon, onion, and apple juice

Herb Roasted Whole Turkey Breast

Brown Sugar & Honey Glazed Pit Ham

Chicken Marsala

Pan fried boneless and skinless chicken breast in a Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms and onions

Baked Cod

Cod filet baked in a lemon butter and white wine sauce

Parmesan Crusted Chicken

Open Faced Pork Chops

SIDES:

Starches (Choose Two):

Herb Roasted Red Potatoes

Roasted Sweet Potato Cubes with Ginger, Maple Syrup and Butter

Garlic Rosemary Mashed Potatoes

Festive Rice – Rice Pilaf with Red Pepper, Onion, Peas, and Lemon Zest

Bacon Mac n Cheese

Vegetables (Choose Two):

Green Beans with Mushrooms and Bacon

Roasted Baby Carrots with Cardamom and Ginger,

Corn Pudding

Roasted Broccoli with Garlic, Lemon Zest, Lemon Juice, and Parmesan

Spicy Candied Yams with Roasted Walnuts

DESSERT:

Includes: Rolls & butter and Cranberry sauce

Pumpkin and Pecan Pie with Whipped Cream

Prestige Holiday Buffet

SALAD:

Apple Pecan Salad

Arugula, dried cranberries, roasted pecans, gala apples, feta cheese, with lemon vinaigrette

ENTRÉES (Choose Two):

Red Wine Braised Oh so Tender Short Ribs

Add $2.00/pp

Roasted Citrus Salmon

With braised fennel and dill

Pork Loin

Stuffed with herbs, apples, cranberries and walnuts

Holiday Stuffed Chicken Breast

Baked boneless and skinless with asiago, spinach, and asparagus

Beef Tenderloin

Sliced beef tenderloin with Madeira mushroom sauce (Add $4.00/pp)

Roasted Bone-In Chicken Breast

With brown butter, sage, and lemon

SIDES:

Starches (Choose Two):

Cranberry Pecan Wild Rice Pilaf

Roasted Zucchini and Carrots with Rosemary, Olive Oil, Pine Nuts, and Fontina

Twice Baked Potatoes with Bacon

Garlic Mashed Potatoes with Asiago Cheese

Cauliflower Mashed Potatoes with Garlic, Scallions, Butter, and Parmesan

Vegetables (Choose Two):

Roasted Cauliflower with Lemon – Parsley Dressing

Roasted Root Vegetables with Fresh Thyme

Tri-Color Baby Carrots Roasted with Rosemary and Spiced Honey

Pan Seared Asparagus with Balsamic Drizzle

Caramelized Brussel Sprouts with Bacon

DESSERT (Choose One):

Flourless Chocolate Cake

Topped with raspberry compote

Door County Cherry Cheesecake

Picnic & Tailgate Party

Includes:

Our famous kettle chips | Fresh buns and condiments | Assorted cookies | Plate and paper service

MEATS:

Choose Three:

-Third Pound All-Beef Hamburger

-Grilled All-Natural Chicken Breast

-Johnsonville Brat in Beer

-All-Beef Hot Dog

-BBQ Pulled Pork

-Italian Sausage with Marinara

-Green Peppers

SIDES:

Choose Three:

-Good Ole American Potato Salad

-Italian Pasta Salad

-Creamy Coleslaw

-Redskin Potato Salad

-Savory Mixed Green Salad

-Fresh Cut Seasonal Fruit

-Fresh Sliced Watermelon

-Cowboy Baked Beans

-Grilled Corn on A Cob (Add $1.50)

-Mac N’ Cheese (Add $1.50)

Southern BBQ Picnic

Olé Border Fiesta

Includes:

Fresh tortillas chips and salsa | Churros | Plate and paper service

MAINS:

Choose Three:

-Carne Asada Tacos

Grilled Steak, Pico De Gallo, Avocado, Cilantro, Queso Fresco Cheese with Corn Tortillas

-Chicken Fajitas

Onions, Red and Green Peppers, Sour Cream with Flour Tortillas

-Steak Fajitas

Onions, Red and Green Peppers, Sour Cream with Flour Tortillas

-Tacos Al Pastor

Grilled Marinated Pork Loin with Pineapple, Onion-Cilantro Relish, Two Chili Salsa, Lime with Corn Tortillas

-Beef Tacos

Ground Beef, Hard Shell, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Cheddar Cheese

SIDES:

Choose Three:

Elote

Grilled Corn cornels

-Frijoles Charros (cooked Pinto Beans with Bacon and Chilies)

-Red Rice with Cilantro and Jalapenos

-Mexican Bean Salad

Corn, Black Beans, Sweet Peppers, Cilantro, Onion, Limes, and Spices

-Refried Beans

-Mango with Cilantro, Coconut and Chili Powder

-Papas Con Rajas (sauteed Potatoes and Chilies with Onion and Cilantro)

-Mexican Salad with Avocado Yogurt Dressing

The Ultimate Grill Out Party

Includes:

Our famous kettle chips | Rolls with butter | Assorted Cookies and Brownies | Condiments | All plate and paper service

Catering Menus

Breakfast

Breakfast Box

Farmers Market Breakfast Casserole

Baked Oatmeal

Spinach and Ham Gruyere Frittata

Good Morning

Build Your Own Breakfast Burrito

Continental

Country Breakfast

Homemade Pancakes

Home Style Corned Beef Hash

Appetizer

Smoked Salmon Platter

Street Skewers

Vegetarian Platter

Get Pickled and Go Nuts Platter

Salsa Trio

Chips and Dips

Vegetable Crudité

Fresh Fruit

Wisconsin Cheese Tray

Cheese and Sausage Tray

Artisan Cheese Platter

Italian Platter

Mini Sandwich Platter

Mini Wrap Platter

Wraps and Minis

Cold Hors D’ Oeuvres

Smoked Salmon Rye Canape

BLT Crostini

Caprese Skewers

Antipasto Skewers

Fresh Fruit Kabobs

Cucumber Canapés

Chicken Avocado Bacon Slider

Shrimp Cocktail

Ricotta & Black Olive Crostini

Bistro Beef Bites

Tomato Bruschetta

Deviled Eggs

Siracha Deviled Eggs with Bacon

Hot Hors D’ Oeuvres

Angus Cheddar Sliders

Buffalo Chicken Slider

Mini Street Taco Quesadilla

Teriyaki Chicken Skewer

Grilled Asian Steak Kabob

Breaded Chicken Tenders

Mini Meatball Skewer

Jalapeno Popper

Mini Chicken Cordon Bleu

Mini Beef Wellington

Spinach Artichoke Tartlet

Buffalo Wings

Rumaki

Sausage Stuffed Mushroom Caps

Spinach & Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms

Vegetable Spring Roll

Crab Cakes

Meatballs

Potato Skins

Mini Quiche

Italian Beef Bites

Rueben Rolls

Italian Sausage

DELI WRAP AND SANDWICH BUFFET | $16

Roasted Turkey Breast Pesto Sandwich

Loaded Steer

Turkey Avocado Club Sandwich

Homemade Chicken or Tuna Salad

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Ham and Cheese on Rye

Portabella

Deli Boards - Build Your Own Sandwiches | $14

Meats

Cheese

Side Choices

BOX LUNCHES

Sandwich Options: